I think this is a good example of urban street photography. The photo
"works." But as with most photography like this, I'm at a bit of a loss to
explain why. I think a significant reason is that it offers a "glimpse"
into urban life. The shot is conflicted. On one hand, it has
interest that makes me want to look. On the other hand, it's not that
interesting. I think the reason it works is because it makes me hungry
for more. If I can find intrigue in something as benign as this, what else
must exist to capture my interest in the city?!
I like the way the taller buildings reflect off of the front of the Vespa. It
helps to convey the urban feeling, and also relays a pleasing yellow cast of the setting
sun on the buildings.
This shot has me thinking about doing a collection of urban street scenes.
---------------
Now, on to a photographic discussion. Ah, the power -- and torment --
that comes with Photoshop.... I debated around a couple
different version of this image. The first debate was whether the yellow
barricade detracted from the image. The second debate was whether this
image was better-served in color, or in black-and-white (duotone). Take a minute to
look at the images I've included below.
I decided that the image is better when I removed the barricade.
Then, I converted the image to black and white using Photoshop's Channel Mixer.
I like the "mood" that's set by the duotone version, but I regret the loss of the reflected
buildings. If I felt it was critically important to the image, I could
have done some work to preserve them.
But then I took a look at the image after returning the barricade to the scene.
Is it just me, or does the color version look best sans-barricade, while the
duotone version looks better with the barricade left in?
Barricade Removed with Clone Tool
Barricade Removed, in Black and White
Barricade Restored: Original Image, as Black and White
Camera: Canon 10D
Lens: 28-135mm, USM EF IS
Mode: Manual
Metering: n/a
Shutter Speed: 1/30 sec
Aperture: f6.7
ISO: 100
Focal Length: 135mm (216mm effective)
Firmware: 1.0.0
Contrast and Sharpness were set to +1.
Filter: Hoya SHMC Circular Polarizer
Original File Size: 3072 x 2048, 1,590K